American think tank Middle East Media Research Institute (MEMRI), a non-profit engaged in translating and analyzing public discourse in the Middle East and the Islamic world, known mostly for monitoring Islamic extremism and antisemitism, has recently reported that several Muslim religious leaders have incited against Israel and the US, including Sheikh Imran Hosein, known for his extremist and conspirationist views. Surprisingly, however, one of the names included was Shamsi Ali, one of New York’s prominent moderate imams, for reportedly inciting against LGBTs and the US, and for justifying the October 7, 2023, massacre by Hamas.
Ali is an Indonesian-American known for his interreligious activism and efforts to promote dialogue between Muslims, Christians, and Jews. He participates in multiple initiatives for peace and democracy, and is a sharp critic of religious extremism and violence in the name of Islam.
Ali is an official and member of multiple organizations: he is the Director of Jamaica Muslim Center in Queen and serves on an Advisory Board member to many interfaith organizations, including Tanenbaum: Combating Religious Prejudice. He also serves on the Board of Directors of the Islamic Society of North America (ISNA) – one of the Islamic community’s umbrella organizations – indicating his broad influence among Muslim Americans.
Ali is among the leaders of interfaith dialogue in the US, particularly in post-9/11 New York. He is a cofounder of the Universal Clergy Coalition-International (UNCC), and Vice President of the Asian-American Coalition USA (AAC-USA) and its UN Representative.
Ali respects individual choice and adopts the principle of “live and let live”. For him, that principle applies not only to sexual, but also to religious and political preferences
In recognition of his extensive interfaith activism in recent decades, Ali won several prestigious awards. In 2002, he was named “Ambassador for Peace” by the International Religious Federation, and in 2006 he was included by New York Magazine among the city’s seven most influential religious leaders. In 2008, he received the Islamic Center of Long Island (ICLA)’s Interfaith Award, and in 2009, the Ellis Island Medal of Honor.
On top of all those, he was listed several times among the 500 Most Influential Muslims by the Royal Islamic Strategic Studies Centre (RISSC) in Jordan, in cooperation with Georgetown University.
As a promoter of interfaith dialogue, Ali has naturally and consistently denounced antisemitism and the harming of Jews and collaborated for many years with Rabbi Mark Schneier, a leading American figure in interfaith dialogue and in rapprochement between New York’s Jewish and Muslim communities in particular.
Even in the explosive post-October 7 era, Ali and Schneier have initiated meetings of Jewish and Muslim Students and jointly denounced threats and violence against American Jews. In a highly charged meeting held at Queens College, New York, Ali was attacked verbally by several Muslim students, who protested his collaboration with Schneier, called him a Zionist, and said he was a persona non grata.
Given all that, MEMRI’s choice of labeling Ali a “radical Islamist” is questionable. Although the think tank referred in brief to the imam’s interfaith activism, but the emphasis on his alleged incitement overshadowed his significant contribution in that regard. A review of the statements attributed to Ali, as well as an exclusive conversation with him, both paint a complex and decisively different picture: some of those statements have been taken out of context, and others have been flatly denied by the imam.
MEMRI also posted photos of Ali and of Zohran Mamdani taken before the municipal elections, probably in an attempt to present the imam as sharing the candidate’s anti-Israeli views
First, the allegations regarding Ali’s statements on LGBTs included reference to the story of Lut (Lot), in both the Quran and Bible, according to which Allah destroyed Sodom in retribution of homosexual acts, as well as sharp criticism on the US recognition of same-sex marriage as part of the supposed moral decline of American society.
In response, Ali emphasized that his views in these matters are clear but respectful: he holds a conservative Muslim concept of family life, according to which marriage is between a man and a woman. He is therefore opposed to the LGBT lifestyle, particularly regarding same-sex marriage. However, he respects individual choice and adopts the principle of “live and let live”.
For him, that principle applies not only to sexual, but also to religious and political preferences. For Ali, this principle is especially valid in the US, where every citizen is equal before the law.
Allegedly, Ali also argued that the US is experiencing a moral crisis and decline, and that it is on the verge of collapse, and that its Muslims are duty bound to renew it and retore it to the “path of righteousness”. He was also quoted as suggesting that its military actions are tantamount to terrorism. The imam was surprised by these allegations, claiming that only an irrational person can argue that he is anti-American that that he wishes the US to be destroyed.
Ali considers himself an American citizen and, and since becoming one, he considers America as a place where he can live securely and comfortably, and the only home for him, his children, and grandchildren.
Ali rejects and denounces attacks that harm and kill innocent civilians, no matter on which side, and makes no distinction between friend and foe
Specifically, regarding his first alleged criticism of the US, note that it is difficult to view such statements as “inciteful”, since they mainly reflect sharp religious-moral criticism against American society, together with the view that Muslims can play a role in redeeming it. In that context, it was important for Ali to emphasize that if indeed he has made statements that could be construed as suggesting that the US is on the verge of collapse, his intent was to warn against processes that could lead to that collapse, rather than expressing hope for America’s destruction.
As for allegations related to Hamas’s terrorist attack on October 7, Ali’s position is even clearer: he rejects and denounces attacks that harm and kill innocent civilians, no matter on which side, and makes no distinction between friend and foe. Still, he is sharply critical of Israel’s conduct of the war in Gaza.
According to the imam, the government’s reaction was extremely disproportionate, leading to mass killing and destruction, to the point that justifies accusations of genocide.
MEMRI also posted photos of Ali and of Zohran Mamdani taken before the municipal elections, probably in an attempt to present the imam as sharing the candidate’s anti-Israeli views. In response, Ali made no secret of his support for Mamdani and even shared that theirs is a close relationship that dates back to Mamdani’s initial steps to run for mayor, although they do not have any formal political alliance.
Ali further addressed Mamdani’s views about Jews and Israel and stressed that the mayor is not opposed to the Jewish community in New York, and added the insight that Mamdani’s is opposed not to the State of Israel as such, but rather to its policy on the Palestinian question, which he considers patently unjust.
Such mislabeling can blur the boundary between criticism of the US and hatred of the West and jeopardize dialogue with Muslim leaders still interested in interfaith dialogue
Ali also emphasized that while he naturally shares agreements and disagreements with Mamdani, and they do not see eye to eye on certain issues, the mayor is a politician who espouses principles of justice, even when they run against his personal interest.
I believe that MEMRI does an important job in monitoring incitement and support for terrorism among Muslim religious leaders, but this is not the first time that it shoots off the mark and targets the wrong imam.
I fear such mislabeling can blur the boundary between criticism of the US and hatred of the West and jeopardize dialogue with Muslim leaders still interested in interfaith dialogue. Precisely in an era of rising antisemitism and the normalization of anti-Israeli sedition in the US, extra care is required not to tarnish those who act to bring Islam and Western democracies closer, build bridges between Jews and Muslims, and combat antisemitism.
